TL;DR
In the realm of breastfeeding pillows, the MyBrestFriend Original Nursing Pillow, Boppy Original Nursing Pillow, MyBrestFriend Twin Nursing Pillow, MyBrestFriend Deluxe Nursing Pillow, and MyBrestFriend Super Deluxe stand out for their unique features and user experiences. The MyBrestFriend Original Nursing Pillow is our Premium Pick for its ergonomic design and support, while the Boppy Original Nursing Pillow offers great value for its versatility. The MyBrestFriend Twin Nursing Pillow is ideal for parents of twins, and the MyBrestFriend Super Deluxe excels in comfort and ease of use.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Price | Rating | |
|---|---|---|---|
 MyBrestFriend Original Nursing Pillow Premium Pick | Check price | ★★★★★ (273) | View on Amazon |
 Boppy Original Nursing Pillow Best Value | Check price | ★★★★☆ | View on Amazon |
 MyBrestFriend Twin Nursing Pillow | Check price | ★★★★★ (17) | View on Amazon |
 MyBrestFriend Deluxe Nursing Pillow Best Budget | Check price | ★★★★★ (179) | View on Amazon |
 ComfyComfy Buckwheat Pillow | Check price | ★★★★★ (47) | View on Amazon |
 MyBrestFriend Super Deluxe Top Rated | Check price | ★★★★★ (56) | View on Amazon |
Quick Summary
Breastfeeding pillows are essential tools for new mothers, providing support and comfort during nursing sessions. They come in various designs, each catering to different needs and preferences. This guide explores the top breastfeeding pillows based on user experiences and community discussions, helping you make an informed decision.
Table of Contents
- TL;DR
- Quick Summary
- Key Buying Factors
- Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Top Product Reviews
- Price Guide
- Personalized Recommendations
- Community Insights
- Final Verdict
Key Buying Factors
Before making your purchase, consider these essential factors:
Support and Comfort
Look for pillows that provide adequate support for both the mother and baby, ensuring a comfortable feeding position.
Ease of Cleaning
Choose pillows with removable and washable covers to maintain hygiene and convenience.
Versatility
Consider pillows that can be used for multiple feeding positions and even as support for tummy time as the baby grows.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Learn from others’ experiences - here are key pitfalls to watch out for:
Choosing the wrong size
Ensure the pillow fits your body type and nursing position to avoid discomfort.
Ignoring cleaning instructions
Select pillows with washable covers to maintain hygiene, especially during the early months.
Not considering future needs
Think about how your breastfeeding journey may evolve and choose a pillow that can adapt to those changes.
Top Product Reviews
Our detailed analysis of the best options available:
MyBrestFriend Original Nursing Pillow
Rating: 4.5 stars from 273 reviews
The MyBrestFriend Original Nursing Pillow is widely praised in various online discussions, particularly on Reddit, for its supportive design and effectiveness in helping mothers achieve a comfortable breastfeeding position. Many users have noted that it provides excellent back support, which is crucial for long nursing sessions. The pillow’s firm structure allows for proper positioning of the baby, making it easier to latch and feed without straining the mother’s arms or back. However, some users have reported mixed experiences, indicating that personal preferences and body types can significantly influence the effectiveness of the pillow. Overall, the sentiment surrounding this product is overwhelmingly positive, with many mothers recommending it as a must-have for breastfeeding.
Features
- Adjustable strap for a secure fit around the waist
- Firm, flat surface that provides stability and support for the baby
User Experiences
- Many users have reported that the MyBrestFriend pillow was a game changer during their breastfeeding journey, particularly appreciating its support for larger breasts and the ability to feed hands-free.
- One mother mentioned that after using the MyBrestFriend pillow, she was able to nurse comfortably for hours without back pain, and it helped her achieve a good latch with her newborn.
Pros
- Provides excellent back support during nursing sessions
- Allows for hands-free feeding, making it easier to multitask
Cons
- Some users found it cumbersome to use, particularly in the early days when managing a newborn’s latching and positioning
Best Use Cases
- Ideal for new mothers who are learning to breastfeed, especially those who have larger breasts or are recovering from a C-section.
Price-Performance Ratio
While the MyBrestFriend Original Nursing Pillow is priced higher than some alternatives, many users feel that its ergonomic design and supportive features justify the cost, making it a worthwhile investment for breastfeeding mothers.
Purchase Options
Buy on AmazonView on Manufacturer’s Website
Boppy Original Nursing Pillow
The Boppy Original Nursing Pillow is a popular choice among breastfeeding mothers, frequently recommended across various online platforms, particularly Reddit. Users appreciate its versatility and ease of use during nursing sessions. However, experiences vary significantly, with some mothers finding it indispensable, while others prefer alternative options like the My Brest Friend pillow. The Boppy is often praised for its comfort and support, especially for new mothers navigating breastfeeding positions, but it may not be suitable for everyone, particularly those with specific body types or preferences.
Features
- C-shaped design for easy positioning during nursing sessions
- Soft and removable cover for easy cleaning
User Experiences
- Many users reported being highly dependent on the Boppy for comfort during nursing, especially in the early weeks. One mother mentioned that she could not nurse without it and found it essential for her back support during long feeding sessions.
Pros
- Versatile and can be used for various breastfeeding positions
- Soft fabric cover is easy to clean and maintain
Cons
- Some users find it cumbersome and prefer firmer nursing pillows for better support
Best Use Cases
- Ideal for new mothers looking for comfort and support during breastfeeding sessions, particularly in the early stages when babies are still learning to latch.
Price-Performance Ratio
The Boppy Original Nursing Pillow is reasonably priced, typically around $40, making it a cost-effective option for the comfort and support it provides during breastfeeding. However, some users feel that investing in a more specialized pillow may yield better results depending on individual needs.
Purchase Options
Buy on AmazonView on Manufacturer’s Website
MyBrestFriend Twin Nursing Pillow
Rating: 4.9 stars from 17 reviews
The MyBrestFriend Twin Nursing Pillow receives consistently positive feedback from parents of multiples, especially for its effectiveness in tandem breastfeeding. Many users highlight its design, which supports both babies comfortably, making it easier to nurse or bottle-feed twins simultaneously. Some parents mention that while it excels in breastfeeding, they also found it useful for bottle feeding, although some prefer other options like the Twin Z for that purpose. Overall, the pillow is considered an essential item for new parents of twins, especially for those who plan to breastfeed.
Features
- Designed specifically for tandem breastfeeding of twins
- Adjustable back support for better posture during feeding
User Experiences
- One user stated that they received the pillow for free and wished they had purchased it earlier, emphasizing its utility for both breastfeeding and bottle feeding. Another mentioned that their husband found it helpful for bottle feeding as well.
Pros
- Excellent support for tandem breastfeeding
- Versatile for both breastfeeding and bottle feeding
Cons
- Some users reported issues with the slick cover making it difficult to keep babies in place
Best Use Cases
- Ideal for breastfeeding and bottle feeding twins simultaneously
Price-Performance Ratio
The MyBrestFriend Twin Nursing Pillow is considered a worthwhile investment by many parents, especially when sourced secondhand or with the option to buy new covers, enhancing its value.
Purchase Options
Buy on AmazonView on Manufacturer’s Website
MyBrestFriend Deluxe Nursing Pillow
Rating: 4.6 stars from 179 reviews
The MyBrestFriend Deluxe Nursing Pillow has garnered a positive reputation among new mothers, particularly those recovering from C-sections and seeking effective breastfeeding support. Users frequently highlight its stability and comfort, noting that it provides essential support during feeding sessions. The design allows for easy adjustments, making it suitable for various body types and feeding positions. Many users appreciate the pillow’s ability to secure around the body, which helps in maintaining proper positioning for both mother and baby. However, some users have mentioned that while the pillow is beneficial in the early months, its necessity decreases as the baby grows and gains better head control. Overall, the pillow is viewed as a valuable tool for easing the breastfeeding journey, especially in the initial weeks postpartum.
Features
- Adjustable strap for a secure fit around the waist
- Firm and stable design that supports the baby during feeding
User Experiences
- Every nursing session but one has been in the nursery chair with the My Brest Friend pillow. I’m 100% dependent on the whole setup. Baby is also 10 weeks.
- I had a C-section and the My Brest Friend pillow was great. It sits under your boobs like on your ribs, and I found it very supportive.
Pros
- Provides excellent support for breastfeeding, especially after C-section
- Adjustable and secure fit around the waist for comfortable use
Cons
- Can feel cumbersome to carry around when out and about
Best Use Cases
- Ideal for new mothers recovering from C-sections who need extra support during breastfeeding
Price-Performance Ratio
While the MyBrestFriend Deluxe Nursing Pillow may be considered slightly pricier than some alternatives, its quality and effectiveness in providing support during breastfeeding make it a worthwhile investment for new mothers.
Purchase Options
Buy on AmazonView on Manufacturer’s Website
ComfyComfy Buckwheat Pillow
Rating: 4.4 stars from 47 reviews
The ComfyComfy Buckwheat Pillow has received a positive reception among users on Reddit, particularly noted for its quality and customer support. The pillow’s design, which utilizes buckwheat hulls, provides a unique sleeping experience that many users find beneficial for neck support and comfort. However, it may not suit everyone due to its firmness and the noise created by the hulls shifting. Overall, users appreciate the pillow’s durability and the ability to adjust the fill to their preference, making it a versatile option for various sleeping styles.
Features
- Adjustable fill for personalized comfort
- Made from organic buckwheat hulls for breathability
User Experiences
- I have the Comfy Comfy Buckwheat pillow and love it. It’s made in the USA and they even sent extra buckwheat to adjust the pillow to your liking.
Pros
- Excellent quality and durability
- Adjustable fill for personalized comfort
Cons
- Can be noisy due to shifting hulls
Best Use Cases
- Ideal for users seeking firm neck support and those who prefer adjustable pillows
Price-Performance Ratio
The ComfyComfy Buckwheat Pillow is reasonably priced for its quality and adjustability, making it a worthwhile investment for those looking for a long-lasting and supportive pillow.
Purchase Options
Buy on AmazonView on Manufacturer’s Website
MyBrestFriend Super Deluxe
Rating: 4.9 stars from 56 reviews
The MyBrestFriend Super Deluxe breastfeeding pillow has garnered positive attention among new mothers for its functionality and comfort during breastfeeding sessions. Users highlight its supportive design, which allows for various feeding positions and ease of use while multitasking. The pillow’s higher back and waterproof cover are particularly appreciated, as they provide additional support and ease of cleaning, making it ideal for new parents dealing with the challenges of breastfeeding.
Features
- Higher back for added support
- Waterproof cover for easy cleaning
User Experiences
- One user shared their experience stating that they could comfortably eat snacks from the pocket of the pillow while breastfeeding, and found it versatile enough to use in various locations around the house, including the couch and even while standing.
Pros
- Provides excellent support during breastfeeding
- Versatile for use in multiple settings
Cons
- Some users may find the pillow bulky to transport around the house
Best Use Cases
- Ideal for breastfeeding in a comfortable seated position on the couch or bed.
Price-Performance Ratio
The MyBrestFriend Super Deluxe is considered a worthwhile investment for its durability and functionality, providing good value for the price, especially for those who breastfeed frequently.
Purchase Options
Buy on AmazonView on Manufacturer’s Website
Price Guide
Find the best option for your budget:
Budget ($30 - $50)
Mid range ($50 - $80)
Premium ($80 and above)
Personalized Recommendations
For Beginners
For Enthusiasts
For Professionals
For Budget conscious
Community Insights
Overall Trends
- The MyBrestFriend pillows are consistently favored for their support and ergonomic design, especially among mothers recovering from C-sections or those nursing twins.
- The Boppy pillow is appreciated for its versatility but is often seen as less supportive compared to MyBrestFriend options.
Top Picks from the Crowd
Controversial Opinions
- Some users prefer using regular pillows or blankets over specialized nursing pillows, citing comfort and adaptability.
Final Verdict
In conclusion, breastfeeding pillows play a crucial role in supporting new mothers during their breastfeeding journey. The MyBrestFriend Original Nursing Pillow stands out as a premium option for its ergonomic design and support, making it ideal for those recovering from C-sections. The Boppy Original Nursing Pillow offers great value for its versatility, while the MyBrestFriend Twin Nursing Pillow is essential for parents of twins. As breastfeeding needs evolve, choosing a pillow that adapts to different stages and preferences is vital. Future trends may see more innovative designs that cater to the diverse needs of breastfeeding mothers, ensuring comfort and support throughout their journey.
Sources
Based on Reddit community discussions:
- Buckwheat pillow? Trying to learn which brands are best and why? from r/BuyItForLife - Score: 267, Comments: 294
- What Baby Products Did You Research to Death… and Then Barely Use? from r/moderatelygranolamoms - Score: 178, Comments: 362
- The boppy pillow must die from r/NewParents - Score: 213, Comments: 109
- Newborn due in 3 weeks, what might we not be prepared for / have ready? from r/BeyondTheBumpUK - Score: 55, Comments: 264
- Boppy Pillow from r/breastfeeding - Score: 127, Comments: 176
- Are nursing pillows really worth it? Expecting 1st baby - c section from r/NewParents - Score: 11, Comments: 119
- Is there any benefit to having two nursing pillows? from r/breastfeeding - Score: 9, Comments: 110
- Do I really need a nursing pillow? from r/BabyBumps - Score: 38, Comments: 79
- What did you ACTUALLY use in your Hospital bag? from r/BeyondTheBumpUK - Score: 14, Comments: 83
- What products or tips and tricks can you share that made breastfeeding/pumping easier for you? from r/breastfeeding - Score: 24, Comments: 69
Note: Product information and prices are subject to change. Please verify details before making a purchase.